The Great HDC Showdown II - Masters of Cinema

[Doc Faustus]

Mulholland Drive is pretty overrated though. As is Lost Highway.

[Zero]

Originally Posted by neverending

No it isn't.

yes - it is.

[neverending]

"Overrated" is just a word people use to make themselves feel good about not liking something other people do.

[Psycom5k]

Its obvious Eraserhead won this, so Robocop gets my vote.

[fortunato]

Definitely Eraserhead.

[Elvis_Christ]

Originally Posted by neverending

"Overrated" is just a word people use to make themselves feel good about not liking something other people do.

To certain extent yes. I personally use it to describe "x" that steals the thunder of "y" thats a better film/book/band/whatever.

[Rayne]

Originally Posted by neverending

"Overrated" is just a word people use to make themselves feel good about not liking something other people do.

That's a very interesting take on it...I always saw it as: Overrated = A lot of people like something just because a lot of people like it, whether it's actually any good or not

Elvis's viewpoint was also thought-provoking :)

[_____V_____]

Eraserhead completes a huge 9-3-2 win!

CHEEBA SCORES THE POINT!


Cheeba - 1
MissM - 0
Newb - 0

[_____V_____]

Someone please come forward and make THREE choices from the above Grid. You may make only ONE choice for each HDC member above.


Alky 2 - STRIKE TWO.

Doc 3 - STRIKE TWO.

F13F1 - STRIKE TWO.

MissM 3 - STRIKE TWO.

Rayne 3 - STRIKE TWO.

Zwoti 1 - STRIKE TWO.



Alky 1, Alky 3 - STRUCK OUT.
Doc 1, Doc 2 - STRUCK OUT.
F13F 2, F13F 3 - STRUCK OUT.
MissM 1, MissM 2 - STRUCK OUT.
Rayne 1, Rayne 2 - STRUCK OUT.
Zwoti 2, Zwoti 3 - STRUCK OUT.


CHEEBA - STRUCK OUT.
FREAK - STRUCK OUT.
NEWB - STRUCK OUT.

[The Krell]

F 13-1
Miss M -2
Cheeba-3