Alan Wake on the 360.
I really shouldn't listen to Zero Punctuation's reviews before planing a game because I can't get his quibbles and complaints out of my head...
- Alan's narrative is awful and annoying (he speaks as though I'm the most retarded audience member on Retarded Audience Member Movie Day)
- Fighting is repetitive
- There isn't a whole lot of "surprise" factor because all of the Bads announce themselves before they attack ("HEY! I'M OVER HERE!")
- The characters are interesting, but I'm too busy running around in the woods to really engage them
It's atmospheric and creepy, but I guess I wish it was more open and less linear. Good concept, but seems thin to me.