Top 5 Comic Book Based Movies
 

What are your top 5 comic book movies?

5-X-Men
4-Superman 3
3-X-Men 2
2-Spider-Man
1-Batman

Those are mine, but they will probably be different after Sin City comes out on Friday.

I should have had Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles in there somewhere too. I forgot about that one.

1) Spider Man
2) Batman
3) Spider Man 2
4) Super Man
5) Batman 2

Not really many good ones...its more fun to do the the worst. Here is my top 5 worst comic book movies ever made.

5) From Hell - Not even Johnny Depp could have saved this one.
4) Batman Forever - Where did Tim Burton go?
3) Fantastic Four - Its not out yet but just a prediction.
2) Batman & Robin - Gay directors and comic books dont mix.
1) Spawn - Bad oh sooo very bad.

Top five I Wish They'd Do :


Silver Surfer
Marvel-DC Teamup (batman - spiderman)
Marvel Teamup (wolverine - spiderman)
Firestorm


well, ok, thats 4

For the life of me I can never figure out why....why....WHY.... whenever a comic thread pops up NOBODY remembers the best comic to movie ever.








Thats right............








Howard the Duck


http://cover09.cduniverse.com/MuzeVi.../64/153764.jpg

Suppsedly it's in production, rumored to come out summer 2006. They're trying to get [brace yourself] Vin Diesel for SS, but there's no official cast as yet. Lets hope he turns it down.


Anyway, my top five.... And they arent in order...Aside from Horror, Superhero movies are my fave:cool:

Batman [The 1st is the undisputed best, IMO]
X-Men [Both]
Spiderman [Both]
Hellboy
League of Extraordinary Gent;emen

1) AKIRA
2) American Splendor
3) Spider-man 2
4) Batman
5) The Crow

Not sure if they'd count:
The Indiana Jones Movies
Pulp Fiction

those were inspired by the old serial comics, but they weren't actually BASED on any of the stories in them. Pulp Fiction especially so. If those count as comic book movies, I'll amend my list.

i believe Pulp Fiction comes more from the cheap dime novels and magazines - moreso than comic books ..
Lurid dectective novels with scantily clad women in peril on the cover .. all text - not graphic..

1.Indiana Jones
2.Batman
3.American Slendor
4.The Crow
5.Spiderman 2

Since the Indiana Jones movies count:

1) AKIRA
2) Raiders of the Lost Ark
3) Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade
4) American Splendor
5) Spider-man 2

I was just using them as a whole but if you use the whole trilogy then...


1.Indiana Jones- Raiders of the Lost Ark
2.Indiana Jones- The Last Crusade
3.Batman
4.American Slendor
5.Spiderman 2


I had the Crow over Spiderman 2 because they were both on the list and I like the Crow more but if I have to choose one than it's Spiderman.

I didn't use them as a whole, only because I really didn't care for Temple of Doom

Akira and Howard the Duck were both great. The Indiana Jones ones are good movies, but this is the first I've ever heard of them being based off a comic book. Anyone know anything more about that?

They aren't really based on any sort of comic book, but are done in an old serial comic book-style

The Crow was a comic book?

#1 The Crow
#2 N/A
#3 N/A
#4 N/A
#5 N/A

#1 - Spider-Man
#2 - Superman
#3 - Blade
#4 - Sin City (Yes, I know it's not out yet)
#5 - Batman

Oh yeah, Blade was another good one I forgot.

Re: Top 5 Comic Book Based Movies
 

1.x-men
2.spiderman
3.blade(i fucking hate steve norrington)
4.crow
5.ghostworld(steve got robbed for best supporting actor!)

Re: Re: Top 5 Comic Book Based Movies
 

against who for what?

Re: Re: Re: Top 5 Comic Book Based Movies
 

..best supporting actor.imdb for the other runners-up and winner(i'd tell ya but i can't recall.)

Revised List


5-Akira
4-Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
3-X-Men 2
2-Spider-Man
1- Batman

Didn't think it made much sense to make a thread for this and since it's basically a comic book discussion and the Crow has been mentioned.....


Is the Crow an action or drama?

the pitt

I'd call it horror/action. Sort of like Blade or Underworld I suppose...

1. Superman The Movie
2. X Men
3. X Men 2
4. Blade
5. Batman

hmm....
 

Here are my top 5 comic book movies in that order :-

1. X-Men 2
2. X-Men
3. Spiderman 2
4. Spiderman
5. Batman Returns

And the worst of the lot :-

1. Spawn (it sucked)
2. Batman & Robin (yawn!)
3. Superman 4 (and the point?)
4. DareDevil (the comic is actually WAAY better!)
5. The Shadow (man wasnt that a waste!!)

i always thought The Phantom was pretty decent ..
Billy Zane is always a watchable actor ..

You could have at least used a picture of Wolverine!:D

Good call, Cyclops is a pussy.

Wolverine
 

Scott Summers has been underplayed in both movies...I m sure he ll develop as the series goes on...

Thank you! Now that I've had my morning drool....................

ahh so you saw my pictures finally ???


:p

Ooooo, baby!:p :D

Re: Wolverine
 

I'm not talking about in the movies, I'm talking about the character in general. He has been a little sissy boy suck up since the X-Men came out in the mid 60's.

TALES FROM THE CRYPT!!

i wish spawn hadn't been such an awful movie.

i like the old shitty spiderman movies. like late 70's when everything looked awful unless it was made to look like it didn't fit a time period.

Sin City was fucking amazing and is without a doubt the greatest comic book adaptation ever....

My list:

1.) Sin City
2.) Batman
3.) Superman
4.) TIE - Spider-Man 2 and X2
5.) Blade and Original Spider-Man

Spider-Man
Batman
X-Men
Spider-Man 2
The Crow