This is easily gonna be the best comic/sci-fi movie all year. I can't believe how close it actually resembles the comics, it's unbelievable how much detail is in just the trailer scenes. I have to see this the day it comes out.

that's a bold thing to say considering that there's 9 months left after it's release.

I can disprove that with 2 words:
Batman Begins

agreed, no way Sin City is going to out do Batman

I am reserving judgement until I see them both but I certainly am not ruling it out. Sin City is driected by the creator of the comic books and that gives it an edge over any other comic movie to date in my mind.

Like I said though, I'm reserving judgment.

I'll make a guess and say Sin City will be better than Batman Begins, it seems more unique... something new.

That and I like me my Jessica Alba.:D

I think the combination of the new "style" of this movie, the fact that the person behind the comic AND a director that makes pretty decent action films are both involved, not to mention a pretty good cast, will make this the better film in the longrun.

That's not to say Batman won't get a bigger audience, or that it won't itself be a great film...but I'm pretty sure I'm gonna be slightly more impressed with sin city.
I'm really looking foward to BOTH of them...with these two, and the fantastic 4 movie coming out, seems this is going to be a pretty good year for the ol' comic type films...

I'm not expecting much from that F4 movie though. It looks kinda lame to me so I have low expectations. If it is good, I'll just be pleasently surprised.

ditto.

AND jessica alba as sue storm... ugh.

In terms of F4 I'm expecting, more or less, a cartoon...something completely and deliberately over the top, this COULD work either way of course...so yeah, I'm not going in expecting to take anything too seriously.
I can only hope it's more worthwhile than the Hulk movie was.