I don't know if he is a good choice for this particular role, but I do think Gosling is a fine actor. In fact, I think overall probably a better pick than Stahl.

Notice how I am criticizing or agreeing with other people's picks but not offering any of my own. Because I don't have a clue...lol.

I think my main problem with Glover would be that he wouldn't fit into it enough. I'd sit there thinking "Man, look at Crispen Glover play the Joker", whether he was doing a good job or not. They need to cast someone who you wouldn't even notice once you started watching. Take, for example, Gary Oldman. I knew he was Gordon. I'd known for a long time. But when I was watching the movie, I never once thought about Oldman. He was Gordon. Ditto for the most part with Bale as Batman. A little ways into the movie, I forgot all about Bale. I think the only person who didn't do that for me was Neeson. I don't think I'd get that with Glover.

Same here. The whole time I was just thinking, "Wow, Neeson's being kind of a prick... Why's he being such a prick?"

Jason Lee would defnatly be a good pick....I could really see that.



And to whoever said Mark Hammil is too old now....I havnt actually SEEN him in anything since Star Wars, so I dont have a clue how he looks. But he can still nail the voice, he does the new cartoon, too. Besides, Nicholson wasnt that young when he did Joker, he was 52. If they started filming the new Batman next year, Hamill would be 55. Not that much difference.

PS- If the pic. of Mark Himill on IMDB is recent, he could definatly look the part...maybe not as good as Glover, but he could still pull it off, I think.

either jason lee or seann william scott would be my choices.

http://www.boxoffice.com/jpg/feb97/pest.jpg

I think John Leguizamo is an amazing actor when he has a serious role.

I thought he was great in Summer of Sam and Executive Decision.

John Leguizamo and Sean William Scott are great choices but there is the point that STE made,

If Leguizamo was doing it you'd notice the hell out of him I don't think he's that good of a character actor. Oldman and Bale became their characters just like they did in The Professional,American Psycho,The Machinist,Dracula ect. ect.

On the other hand with Scott and Leguizamo they are fine actors but I don't think they can blend in and actually become the Joker, I personally know that I'd think to myself ''cool Stifler's playing the Joker''.

Oh, I was never saying Leguizamo would be a good joker, I was just saying he's a great actor.

But Sean William Scott would be a terrible joker.

I actually heard that Crispin Glover was under consideration fo the role. I think he'd be a perfect Joker. They can stop looking.