Mothman and Duke seem to fit together well, so I'll go with them.

MARYA ZALESKA
&
FRANK N FURTER

now THAT'S a match

Marya for the win.

Marya & Frank N.

Marya and Frank

Marya and Frank-N-Furter

Disease & Edgar

Marya and Frank. Duke's obviously overcompensating for gender insecurities which the presence of transvestitism would surely exploit. Edgar would just be confused. And I don't know if Disease and Mothman could pick up that much slack, especially against a guy who's man enough to dress up as a vampire grandma to critique vintage horror. Plus, it's obvious that Frank works out.

disease & edgar

Mothman and Duke

Marya and Frank...disturbing pair.