God dammit....

Book of Shadows is a good, atmospheric movie. If it didn't suffer from the Blair Witch tag and was released as a completely stand alone movie people would talk about it differently. Severely underrated.

Blair Witch - B
Book of Shadows - B+

If it was released as a completely stand-alone movie, it would be forgotten as the B-movie trash that it is ;)

Feed the fire, penguin boy:p

You're right about the forgotten part, though. If BW2 had been released as a stand alone, no one would remember it. They went for quick money, and they got what they deserved. It's sad to me that some of these movies could be great hidden gems (like a later Hellraiser or Halloween III) had they not been blackballed by association.

Blair Witch Project= B

Book of Shadows= D+

The Blair Witch Project - C
Book of Shadows: Blair Witch 2 - C+

The Blair Witch Project= B

(Haven't seen the book of shadows)

Blair Witch - B-
Book of Shadows - B+

I second Flayed on the Book of Shadows.

Blair Witch has already gotten a pretty good response. I'll leave it open for grading until mid day Wednesday and then we'll move on.

If anyone wants to request which franchise we do next, now's the time.

Blair Witch P - A+
BW Book of Shadows - F- (can there be an F minus - if so this is it)